Message us on WhatsApp
    Insights

    Foundations

    Why Do I Assume I Know What Other People Are Thinking?

    16 November 2026 · Samyama Team

    Why Do I Assume I Know What Other People Are Thinking?

    Someone doesn't reply to your message. You notice they've been online, perhaps even read it, but there's no response. You start wondering whether you've upset them. Maybe they're annoyed, or perhaps they're pulling away. You replay your last conversation, looking for something you might have said wrong. By the time they reply, you've already had an entire conversation with them in your head, even though they haven't actually said anything.

    It's a familiar experience, and it raises an interesting question. How much of what we believe about other people comes from what they've actually said or done, and how much comes from the stories we've created about them?

    The Stories We Create About Other People

    We do this all the time, often without noticing. A friend seems quieter than usual, and we assume something is wrong. A partner doesn't respond with the warmth we expected, and we feel rejected. Someone challenges an idea, and we hear criticism rather than curiosity. Something happens outside us, and almost immediately we give it meaning.

    Sometimes our interpretation is accurate. We know the people in our lives, and experience can help us recognise when something has changed. But sometimes we're responding less to what happened and more to the story we've created about it. Once we believe that story, it begins to influence how we behave. We might withdraw before someone has rejected us, become defensive before anyone has criticised us, apologise for something we haven't done, or feel resentful about an intention the other person never had. Without realising it, we can find ourselves responding to a relationship that exists partly in our imagination.

    Why Do We Make These Assumptions?

    Human beings are constantly trying to make sense of the world around them. We notice expressions, tone of voice, pauses, gestures and changes in behaviour, then use what we know to interpret them. It's a useful ability. Without it, navigating relationships would be extraordinarily difficult. But our interpretations are influenced by more than what's happening in the present moment.

    Our expectations, previous experiences, insecurities and familiar relationship patterns can all shape the meaning we give to someone else's behaviour. If we've experienced rejection, we may become particularly alert to signs that someone is pulling away. If conflict has felt threatening in the past, a simple disagreement might feel much bigger than it is. Sometimes we project our own feelings or fears onto another person, imagining that they are experiencing something that actually belongs to us.

    None of this means we're doing something wrong. These are understandable ways of trying to navigate uncertainty and protect ourselves. The difficulty begins when we forget that our interpretation is just that: an interpretation. We stop wondering whether our story is true and begin behaving as though we know it is.

    What Do I Actually Know?

    There's a simple but surprisingly revealing distinction we can practise making: what did I actually observe, and what am I assuming?

    Imagine a friend cancels your plans at the last minute. What you know is that they've cancelled. What you might assume is that they don't value your friendship, that they're avoiding you, or that you've become less important to them. Those explanations might be possible, but so are many others. Perhaps they're exhausted, something difficult is happening in their life, or they simply need an evening alone.

    The point isn't to replace a negative assumption with a positive one. That would still be inventing a story. The invitation is to recognise the difference between what we know and what we don't, and to become curious about what happens inside us when we don't know. Does uncertainty make us anxious? Do we feel compelled to seek reassurance? Do we withdraw, become angry, or immediately try to fix something? Those reactions can tell us something about our own patterns, regardless of what the other person is actually thinking.

    When Our Assumptions Become Part of the Problem

    Sometimes the assumptions we make about a relationship begin to shape the relationship itself. Imagine believing that someone is disappointed in you. You become cautious around them, hold back, explain yourself too much, or stop sharing things you would normally say. They notice that something has changed and become a little more distant themselves. Now you have what appears to be evidence that your original assumption was correct, when perhaps the distance between you began with a misunderstanding neither of you recognised.

    This doesn't mean every relationship difficulty is something we've imagined. People do reject, criticise, deceive and hurt one another, and sometimes our concerns are entirely justified. But when we're willing to question our assumptions, we create room for a different possibility. Instead of reacting to what we believe someone means, we can begin to discover what is actually happening between us.

    What Changes When We Become Curious?

    One of the most useful practices in Authentic Relating is learning to distinguish observation from interpretation. Rather than immediately deciding what another person is thinking or feeling, we become interested in our own experience and how we're responding to theirs.

    For example, we might say, "When you went quiet during our conversation, I started worrying that I'd upset you." That's different from saying, "You were obviously annoyed with me." The first expresses something we experienced while leaving room for the other person's reality. The second presents our interpretation as a fact. That small difference can change the direction of a conversation, giving the other person an opportunity to tell us something we didn't know while allowing us to take responsibility for our own feelings without assuming responsibility for theirs.

    Sometimes what we discover is uncomfortable. Perhaps we've been avoiding a difficult conversation, we're afraid of hearing an answer we don't want, or we've been expecting another person to reassure us about something we haven't yet learned to recognise within ourselves. Curiosity doesn't guarantee that a conversation will be easy, or that every relationship can be repaired, but it can help us approach one another with a little less certainty and a little more openness.

    Understanding Ourselves While We're Relating

    It's one thing to recognise these patterns when we're alone, reflecting on a conversation that happened yesterday. It's another to notice them while we're actually sitting opposite someone. We might understand intellectually that we tend to seek approval, yet still feel the urge to agree when someone expresses a different opinion. We might know that we become defensive when we feel misunderstood, yet struggle to remain open when someone challenges us.

    This is where practising awareness in relationship can become particularly revealing. Through listening, honest expression, noticing assumptions and exploring boundaries, we can begin to recognise our familiar responses as they arise. We don't have to eliminate those responses or become perfect communicators. Sometimes the first meaningful change is simply noticing what we're doing before we do it, creating a little space in which we may discover that we have a choice.

    Perhaps We Don't Know as Much as We Think

    The next time someone says something that leaves you feeling hurt, rejected or misunderstood, you might pause and ask yourself what actually happened, what story you're telling yourself about it, and what you might discover if you became curious instead of certain.

    You may find that your original interpretation was right, discover something entirely different, or realise that the story you've been telling yourself reveals something important about your own fears, expectations or needs. The invitation isn't to distrust your instincts or endlessly question your feelings. It's simply to remember that another person's inner world is not always as obvious as it seems, and that sometimes the most meaningful change in a relationship begins when we stop assuming we already know the other person's story.

    What if, instead of being certain about what someone else is thinking, we became curious enough to ask?